URPE is deeply saddened by the loss of renowned economist Anwar Shaikh, and is pleased to share this tribute to Anwar by Sungur Savran. Anwar was an early member of URPE, published his work in the Review of Radical Political Economics, and delivered the David Gordon Memorial Lecture in 2019.
In Memoriam: Anwar Shaikh (1945-2026)
By Sungur Savran
One of the greatest Marxist economists of the 20th century passed away on 6 October. Anwar Shaikh taught for half a century at the Economics Department of the Graduate Faculty of the New School for Social Research in downtown New York and was, in fact, one of the decisive figures in the formation of a graduate programme that served as a special school of Marxist political economy of worldwide renown, catering to the needs of a high-quality student body from all over the world. In his time, for many decades, the Economics Department offered students a special track in political economy, which was firmly based on a close reading of Marx’s Capital during the first year of the M.A. programme and also informed the way the doctoral programme was designed. In the M.A. programme, Capital volume one was studied during the first semester, with volumes two and three then being taken up during the second. Anwar also taught courses of advanced political economy bringing the students up to date on the debates within the field of political economy throughout the twentieth century. All this was only the tip of the iceberg for the work that went into the formation of a whole special school of political economy of which Anwar was, so to speak, the chef d’orchestre, the conductor. We will return to the nature of this school of thought presently, after we discuss the special contribution Anwar made to political economy in his own scientific work throughout his entire career.
His contribution was unique. Those well-versed in the historical development of Marxist political economy will remember that the specific moment in which he entered the field was the heyday of Piero Sraffa’s impact on economics, (often dubbed “the neo-Ricardian debate”, mistakenly in this writer’s opinion, but that would take as afar from our purpose in this tribute). Production of Commodities by Means of Commodities was published, simultaneously in English and Sraffa’s own native Italian, in the year 1960 and immediately set off a chain of debates. The so-called “Cambridge controversy” (Cambridge, England vs. Cambridge, Mass.), fraught with mortal danger for neoclassical economics, was raging when Anwar started his doctoral work in the late 1960s. The 1970s then brought a new aspect to the debate: a furious controversy between those who claimed that Marx’s theory of value and surplus value was marred by the alleged inconsistencies of the transformation of values (developed in volume one of Capital) into prices of production (volume three), and had best be substituted by Sraffa’s framework. It was claimed that the latter was perfectly consistent. Among the proponents of this new onslaught were not only pure-bred Sraffians like Piero Garegnani or Alessandro Roncaglia, but also venerable figures of a previous generation of Marxists, such as Maurice Dobb and Ronald Meek, as well as younger writers that were educated in the Marxist tradition, most notably Ian Steedman.
Anwar played a prominent role in the defence of Marx’s theory of value and surplus value against the Sraffian onslaught. He started to grapple with the “transformation problem” as early as his doctoral dissertation and showed, in the early 1970s, more or less simultaneously with Morishima, that the generally accepted “solution” to the transformation problem was mathematically identical with the results reached through a series of reiterations of Marx’s transformation procedure (hence commonly called the “iterative method”). We stop here for a moment to make one of the most important points about the kind of thinker Anwar was: whatever theoretical conclusions one may draw from this mathematical derivation, this finding is highly symbolic of each and every proposition that Anwar put forward in his later theoretical endeavours: his thinking was and remained to the end highly original, crystal-clear in its progression from the premisses to the conclusions, and always full of possibilities for further development.
Lest the reader be misled, let us add, before we move on to the major strands of Anwar’s contribution to political economy, that his mathematically original elucidation of the so-called “transformation problem” was not the only line of intervention in the neo-Ricardianism vs. Marxism controversy. In an overall conjuncture in which the defenders of Marx’s theory of value and surplus value were almost exclusively on the defensive, he was one of the very few to question the merits of Sraffa’s own theoretical approach on a number of issues, again, on the basis of logically sound and theoretically original arguments.
Anwar was not the type of theoretician who confined his studies to a single issue or domain. He made forays into many areas and always brought something new, something that was peculiarly his contribution to each of these. We cannot go into his many other important interventions in the theoretical debates of his time. Let us mention a brief list of some of the most significant of these: the “humbug production function”, in the context of which he showed that this centrepiece of neoclassical economics was not an empirically falsifiable proposition but simply an accounting identity; the competition debate in which his “Marxian competition” (which he later came to dub “real competition” the more he worked on it) was counterposed to the idyllic assumption of “perfect competition” (a debate to which the Cambridge Journal of Economics was to devote an entire issue); the elucidation of the distinction productive-unproductive labour in Marxist political economy; the application of Marx’s labour theory of value to international trade, which led to a fruitful exchange between the rather young Anwar and the authoritative figure of Professor Joan Robinson. In all of these different areas and many others that we pass over here, again, the main conclusion that we drew above with respect to his engagement with the “transformation problem”, was perfectly valid: his interventions were original, crystal-clear in their logic, and advanced the debate enormously.
Yet, however important those interventions are, his enormous and timeless contribution lies elsewhere. Anwar is the discoverer of a new continent in political economy. His insistence on providing proof and evidence for the propositions of science led him toward a search for ways to measure variables that are peculiar to the Marxist analysis of capitalism: values, productive and unproductive labour, surplus value, the rate of surplus value, the net social wage etc. However, Marxist variables lie beneath the surface of the way the capitalist economy presents itself to the eye and are not amenable to be “read off” from everyday statistics (i.e. national income accounts). So, Anwar inverted the process through which Marx analysed real life under capitalism and arrived at what we may call a process of “reverse transformation” to reach down to the level of values (“direct prices” in his terminology once labour values were expressed in terms of the monetary unit) and surplus value from the level of prices of production and the even more superficial level of market prices. This formed the basis of an entirely original process of measurement of economic variables peculiar to Marxism. This bold and original procedure found its expression in one of the most important works of Marxist political economy in the 20th century, Measuring the Wealth of Nations: The Political Economy of National Accounts, a book Anwar co-authored with E. Ahmet Tonak, earlier his doctoral student, and from a certain point in the latter’s studies, his colleague (they were to become very close friends through to the end of Anwar’s life).
This is where we return to the significance of what Anwar achieved at the New School through his effort at creating a solid programme of Marxist political economy. Throughout his half century of teaching there, he helped educate many Marxist economists from all around the world, who then each went on to do the same kind of research each on the economy of their own countries. This way, an entire school of quantitative or empirical Marxism or of Marxist value theory came into being! True, there were others before them who tried their hand at such empirical measurement of Marx-specific categories. Anwar and Ahmet have always pointed this out and have also humbly mentioned on all occasions that there were others who, contemporaneously with them, worked in the same field and achieved great success as well. Whatever assessment one may make personally of the merits of the research of each of these pioneers, it is only Anwar’s combination of the thoroughgoing education he provided his students at the New School and the rigorous methodology he developed that made possible the formation of an entire school of thinking and research to come into existence. Today, there still flows forth a series of studies relative to different countries of the world and others that carry out similar measurements at the level of the entire world. Most of these researchers are either directly or indirectly treading the path first opened by Anwar.
There is, finally, as the third branch of his contribution to political economy, the book Capitalism: Competition, Conflict, Crises, published in 2016 after many long years or even decades of work devoted to what may fairly be regarded as the fruit of his Lebenswerk, as the Germans say, since this book was in fact the fruit of an entire life’s work. We find a somewhat different Anwar Shaikh in this, his final major work. Gone are the emphasis of a Marxist outlook and also the tenacious effort to prove to the world that Marx’s approach to the fundamentals of modern economic life provides indisputably the best and the most correct approach to the multitude of problems posed by capitalism. Anwar still considers his work as the continuation of the tradition of political economy, composed of the Classical School, with Smith and Ricardo heading the lot, and the specific contribution of Marx, as well as that of Keynes. But the abundance of references to Marx and in particular to Capital are gone.
Capitalism is a more self-referential book, gently implying to the reader that a new school of thinking in the field of economics (or political economy) is being offered in this new work. The book, a thousand pages long, covers almost every field of economics that concerns those economies that are conventionally considered to be advanced. This means that it has almost nothing to say about those countries which were or are still engaged in the construction of socialism, based on planned economies or what some consider to be the socialist market, as well as those poor and very poor countries where industrial development and technological know-how is low and relations with imperialism rule the functioning of the economy. (We say “almost nothing” since when Anwar discusses international trade or finance etc., he necessarily engages topics that involve that poorer kind of country as well as the advanced ones.)
A full assessment of Capitalism will only be possible with the passage of time and its level of influence will also depend on the real developments in the world.
This writer was a colleague of Anwar’s for a brief period of several years at the Department of Economics of the Graduate Faculty of the NSSR. It was E Ahmet Tonak, a compatriot of mine, who introduced us when I was a visiting professor in the United States at another college. I was asked by Anwar to teach at the summer school of the Department of Economics of the Graduate Faculty, which I gladly did for several years between 1987 and 1994. He and I became close enough for him to put me up in his home as a guest when I needed temporary accommodation. In 1990, he offered me a one-year position in the Department of Economics, asking me to teach Capital to first-year students. I had to decline, for a full-year teaching job would seriously hamper my political work in Turkey. I have no doubt that we would have gotten much closer had I been able to comply with his offer.
Anwar’s passing away has of course caused great sorrow among his loved ones and friends and students, among all who used to call him “Anu”. But it does not in the least imply a diminution of his intellectual influence. For his work is now cast in the precious stone of that entire school of talented students of his in the field of quantitative Marxism. What finer gravestone for a great thinker?